Skip to content
Buyersagents.com.au
Buy first or sell first when you upgrade your home?

Buy first or sell first when you upgrade your home?

Today
5 min read
5 views

The short answer: Sell first if you can't carry two loans, because it fixes your budget before you commit. Buy first if the right home matters more than the money and you can hold both properties for months. Either way, the settlement dates and your broker's bridging options decide how big the risk really is.

Every upgrade carries one of two risks

Most people planning an upgrade start by looking at houses. In my work as a buyers agent, the question that causes more trouble is the order: sell first, or buy first. Each choice protects you from one risk and leaves you holding the other.

  • Sell first, and you know exactly what you have to spend. The risk is that prices rise, or the right home doesn't come up, before you have somewhere to go.
  • Buy first, and you secure the home you want. The risk is that your sale takes longer or comes in lower than you planned, while you pay for two properties.

Neither order is safe, so the real choice is which risk you can carry.

When selling first makes sense

  • Your budget only works with the sale price in hand. If a lower sale would change what you can buy, sell first.
  • You can't hold two loans. Two sets of repayments, rates and insurance add up quickly, even for a few months.
  • Your local market is slow. If homes like yours take a while to sell, buying first puts you on the clock.

The cost is that you may need to rent for a while, move twice, or buy under time pressure. Plan for it: a short-term rental, storage and two moves can cost several thousand dollars.

When buying first makes sense

  • The home you want is rare. A particular street, school catchment or block that rarely comes up can justify the risk.
  • You can hold both. Your broker has confirmed you can service both loans, or bridge between them, if the sale takes months.
  • Your home will sell well. It's in a street and condition buyers compete for, and your price is based on recent comparable sales, not hope.

The cost is the overlap: interest on two loans, rates, insurance, and the pressure to accept a lower offer because you need the sale.

Settlement dates can do some of the work

You rarely have to choose one extreme. A few tools narrow the gap between the two settlements:

  • A long settlement on your sale, so you have time to find and buy the next home.
  • A short or flexible settlement on your purchase, timed to land close to your sale.
  • A rent back, where you stay in the home you've sold for a few weeks and pay rent to the buyer.
  • A subject-to-sale condition on your purchase. It protects you, but it makes your offer weaker, and some sellers won't accept it.

Each of these is a contract term, so your conveyancer should draft or review it. Bridging finance, and whether a lender will take on both loans, is a question for your mortgage broker.

Work out the worst case before you choose

Whichever way you go, write down two numbers:

  1. If you buy first: what would six months of holding both properties cost, and what's the lowest sale price you could accept and still be fine?
  2. If you sell first: what would three to six months of renting and two moves cost, and how much would prices need to rise before your budget no longer works?

The free ++Holding Power Check++ tests repayments at your full pre-approval, which helps with the first number. Check your home's likely sale price with three to five recent comparable sales, using the same method as ++working out what a house is worth before you offer++.

If prices are falling when you upgrade, the order matters less than you might think, because you're selling and buying in the same market. The ++gap between the two prices++ is the number that counts.

Choose the risk you can carry

The rule I give clients: sell first unless you can comfortably hold both properties for six months and the home you're buying is hard to replace. If you buy first, set your lowest acceptable sale price before you sign, not after.

Timing a purchase around a sale is a big part of what we do for ++home buyers in South East Queensland++. Which of the two worst cases could you live with?

Frequently asked questions

Should I sell my house before buying another?

Sell first if your budget depends on the sale price or you can't carry two loans. Buy first only if you can hold both properties for months and the home you want is hard to replace.

What is a rent back when selling a house?

A rent back lets you stay in the home you've sold for an agreed period after settlement, paying rent to the buyer. It gives you time to settle on your next home without moving twice.

How do I avoid paying two mortgages when upgrading?

Line up the settlement dates: a long settlement on your sale, a flexible one on your purchase, or a subject-to-sale condition. Your conveyancer drafts the terms, and your broker can explain bridging options.

Disclaimer: The information in this article is general in nature and does not take into account your personal objectives, financial situation, or needs. It is not financial, legal, or tax advice. The Nelis Group accepts no liability for actions taken based on this content. You should seek independent advice from a relevant licensed professional before making any decisions and always confirm the latest rules and thresholds with your state revenue office or relevant authority.