Skip to content
Buyersagents.com.au
Do you need a buyers agent? When you don't

Do you need a buyers agent? When you don't

Today
6 min read
5 views

The short answer: You may not need a buyers agent if you know the area, have time to inspect and research, can price from comparable sales and can walk away under pressure. You probably do if you're buying somewhere you don't live, are short on time or are building a portfolio. The fee only pays off if it changes the decision.

Plenty of people buy well without one

I'm a buyers agent, so you would expect me to say everyone needs one. They don't. Plenty of people buy well on their own, and some of the best decisions I have seen were made by buyers who did the work themselves.

What decides it isn't confidence. It is whether you can do the specific jobs a buyers agent does, and whether you have the time to do them properly.

You probably don't need one if all of these are true

  • You know the area. You've lived there, you know which streets flood, which ones carry traffic and which side of the main road people prefer.
  • You have time. Inspections, reading contracts, chasing building and pest reports and tracking sales takes hours a week for months.
  • You can price it yourself. You can find three to five true comparable sales, rate each one against the property, and set a walk-away number before you inspect.
  • You can walk away. At auction or in a tight negotiation, you will stop at your number.
  • The purchase is a one-off. A home you plan to stay in for a long time, rather than one step in a sequence.

A home buyer upgrading within a suburb they know well often ticks every box. If that is you, a good conveyancer, a thorough building and pest inspector and a broker may be all you need.

You probably do if any of these apply

  • You're buying somewhere you don't live. This is the most common case for investors. Rentvestors in particular often buy hundreds of kilometres from where they rent, in a market they've never walked.
  • You don't have the hours. Professionals and athletes are often in this group. An athlete balancing training, a day job and selection doesn't have twelve Saturday mornings to spend at open homes.
  • The purchase has to fit a plan. If this property needs to fund the next one, its job, price point and timing matter as much as the property itself.
  • You've overpaid before, or nearly did. Some people know they buy on emotion. Knowing that is useful.

What you are really paying for

The visible part is finding a property. The less visible part is the filtering, the pricing and the plan around it, which ++what a buyers agent does, step by step++ lays out in full.

My first purchase, in Kallangur in 2014, was bought without a buyers agent and without a plan. I could find a property. Nobody asked what it was meant to do next, including me, and the first few years taught me what that question was worth. I didn't need someone to find me a house. I needed someone to ask the right questions before I bought one.

A fee is certain. Its value is in the mistake you avoid, and you never get to see that. So the test isn't "can I find a property?" It is "will someone else's process change what I buy, what I pay, or whether I buy at all?"

A five-question test before you pay anyone

  1. Do I know this market well enough to rule out a street, not just a suburb? (++How to research a suburb++ shows what that takes.)
  2. Can I name three comparable sales and say whether each is better or worse than the property?
  3. Do I know what I can hold if rates rise or the property sits empty?
  4. Do I know what this purchase is for, in one sentence?
  5. Will I stop at my number when the selling agent tells me someone else is close?

Four or five clear yeses: you may be fine on your own. Two or more noes: the gaps are the jobs a buyers agent does, and you can weigh the fee against them.

For question 3, the free ++Holding Power Check++ shows what a rate rise or an empty month would do to your cash flow.

If you do hire one, check the process, not the pitch

Ask how they are paid and whether the fee rises with the price; our guide to ++buyers agent fees++ explains the options. Ask whether they take any payment from developers, sellers or selling agents; if yes, walk away. Ask whether they invest themselves, and whether they will ever tell you not to buy.

Lending and tax questions don't sit with a buyers agent. They sit with your mortgage broker and accountant, and a good buyers agent works alongside them.

If you're buying a home in South East Queensland, our ++owner-occupier buyers agent++ page sets out where we help and where you might not need us.

Where I land: pay for a buyers agent when the gaps in your knowledge or time are bigger than the fee, and not to feel more confident about a decision you could make well on your own. Which of the five questions would you answer no to?

Frequently asked questions

Do I need a buyers agent to buy a house?

Not always. If you know the area, have time to research, can price from comparable sales and can walk away under pressure, you may buy well on your own with a good conveyancer and inspector.

When is a buyers agent worth it?

When you're buying in a market you don't live in, don't have the time to research and inspect, or need the purchase to fit a longer plan. The fee pays off if it changes what you buy or pay.

What should I ask a buyers agent before hiring one?

Ask how they're paid, whether the fee rises with the price, whether they take payments from developers or sellers, whether they invest themselves, and whether they'll ever tell you not to buy.

Disclaimer: The information in this article is general in nature and does not take into account your personal objectives, financial situation, or needs. It is not financial, legal, or tax advice. The Nelis Group accepts no liability for actions taken based on this content. You should seek independent advice from a relevant licensed professional before making any decisions and always confirm the latest rules and thresholds with your state revenue office or relevant authority.