Skip to content
Buyersagents.com.au
How to work out what a house is worth before you offer

How to work out what a house is worth before you offer

Today
4 min read
8 views

The short answer: Find three to five recent sales of truly similar homes nearby, rate each one superior, similar or inferior to the house you want, and build a value range from them. The bottom of the range is fair value; the top is where you'd be overpaying. Set your walk-away price from that range before you inspect, not after.

The asking price is a marketing number

As a buyers agent, the most expensive mistake I see home buyers make is letting the asking price decide what they think a home is worth. The selling agent's job is to get the seller the highest price. A price guide is set to bring buyers through the door, not to tell you what the home is worth.

Your own value range, built from real sales, is the only number that works for you.

Step 1: choose true comparable sales

A comparable sale is a recent sale of a home that a buyer of this house would also have considered. Match like with like:

  • Same type of home: house with house, townhouse with townhouse.
  • Similar size: bedrooms, bathrooms, car spaces and land size.
  • Same area: ideally the same suburb, within about two and a half kilometres.
  • Recent: sold in the last three to twelve months. Older sales need more adjustment.

A sale next door isn't a comparable if it's a different kind of property. A four bedroom house on 600 square metres doesn't tell you much about a three bedroom house on 400.

You can find sold prices on the major property portals. Look at the photos and floor plans as well as the headline numbers.

Step 2: rate each one superior, similar or inferior

For each comparable, ask whether it's better, about the same or worse than the house you're pricing. Look at:

  • The street: quiet street or main road, train line, powerlines, flood overlay.
  • The block: size, slope, orientation and usable yard.
  • The house: condition, layout, renovations and the size of the smallest bedroom.

Write a short reason for each rating. If two sales are superior and two are inferior, the house you want sits between them.

Step 3: build a range, then adjust for the market

Line the comparables up by price. The house you're pricing belongs near the sales you rated similar, below the superior ones and above the inferior ones. That gives you a range.

Then adjust for timing. If the market has softened since the older sales, lean to the bottom of the range. If it's been rising, older sales may understate today's value.

The bottom of the range is fair value. The top is where you would start to overpay.

Step 4: set your walk-away price before you inspect

Write your walk-away number down before you go to the open home, and before you fall for the kitchen. If the price passes it, the decision has already been made.

It's also the step most buyers skip, because once you've pictured yourself living there, every number starts to look reasonable.

Two other checks belong next to the price:

What comparable sales can't tell you

Sales show what buyers paid, not what they'd pay today in a different market. They miss things you only see in person, like noise, smell or a neighbour's extension. And a lender's valuation can still come in lower than your price, which is a question for your broker before you commit.

Price it before you see it

My rule: never inspect a home you haven't priced. If you can't find three true comparables, treat the price with more caution, not less.

We price every home this way before a client inspects it; there's more on ++how we work with home buyers++. What would your walk-away number be on the home you're watching?

Frequently asked questions

How do I know what a house is worth?

Find three to five recent sales of similar homes nearby, rate each one better, similar or worse than the house you want, and build a value range. The bottom of the range is fair value.

How much should I offer on a house?

Offer from your own value range, not the asking price. Start near the bottom of the range, and set a walk-away price from the top before you inspect.

What is a comparable sale?

A recent sale of a home a buyer of this house would also have considered: the same type, similar size and block, in the same area, sold within the last three to twelve months.

Disclaimer: The information in this article is general in nature and does not take into account your personal objectives, financial situation, or needs. It is not financial, legal, or tax advice. The Nelis Group accepts no liability for actions taken based on this content. You should seek independent advice from a relevant licensed professional before making any decisions and always confirm the latest rules and thresholds with your state revenue office or relevant authority.

[Schema Topics]