Skip to content
Buyersagents.com.au
Interest only or principal and interest for investors?

Interest only or principal and interest for investors?

Today
6 min read
5 views

The short answer: On my own $655,000 investment purchase, interest only costs about $4,450 a month against about $4,930 on principal and interest. Interest only frees cash for the buffer and the next purchase. The cost is no debt reduction, often a higher rate and a bigger repayment when the period ends. Which loan suits you is a broker's call.

The choice is about cash now versus debt later

I'm a buyers agent, not a mortgage broker. I can't tell you which loan to take, and nothing here is lending advice. Loan type, lender and structure are decisions for a licensed mortgage broker, and the tax side sits with your accountant.

What I can do is show the trade-off. When I model a purchase for a client, they see the cash flow both ways, and I run my own purchases the same way. Here is one of mine, so you can see the numbers before you have that conversation with your broker.

What the difference costs on my own purchase

In 2026 I bought an investment property in Wodonga for $655,000. The loan is interest only. The purchase loan is 80% of the price, and the deposit and buying costs came from ++equity++, so the total borrowing is about 105% of the price.

Loan Amount Rate

Interest only, per month New purchase loan (80%) $524,000 8% about $3,490

Equity for deposit and costs $163,750; 7%, with a major lender: about $960**; total: $ 687,750; about $4,450**

On principal and interest over 30 years, the same debt would cost about $4,930 a month. Interest only keeps about $490 a month, or roughly $110 a week, in my account.

The number most people miss is the reset. Both loans are interest only for five years. If nothing changed, they would then switch to principal and interest over the remaining 25 years, and the repayment would rise to about $5,200 a month: about $750 more, overnight.

The 8% rate on the new loan is part of the cost too. The plan is to refinance it onto a better rate at the 12-month mark, ideally sooner. If it moved to 7%, the interest only repayment on that loan would fall by about $440 a month. But a refinance depends on the valuation and lending policy at the time, so I kept a larger buffer in case it takes longer. I wrote about that decision in ++why I didn't wait for a better interest rate to buy++.

Ask your broker for both rates and both repayments, not just one, and what a refinance would need to go through.

What interest-only buys you

  • Holding power. A lower repayment means a smaller weekly gap, and the same buffer lasts longer if a property sits empty or rates rise.
  • Cash for the next step. The money you aren't repaying can build your buffer or the next deposit. The free ++Buffer Calculator++ shows how big that buffer needs to be.
  • Flexibility. You can still put spare cash in an offset, which reduces interest while keeping the money available.

This is why many investors use interest only while they are still building: the aim is to hold more property, sooner, without being forced to sell.

What it costs you

  • No debt reduction. Ten years of interest only leaves the loan where it started. Any equity comes from growth alone.
  • Often a higher rate. The extra interest is real money every month.
  • The reset. The jump at the end of the period can land at the worst time: a rate rise, a vacancy or a lower income year.
  • Lending limits. Lenders assess your borrowing on the higher principal and interest repayment over the remaining term, and extensions aren't guaranteed.

How the right answer changes over time

The same investor can need different answers at different stages.

While you're building a portfolio, cash and holding power usually matter most. Many investors accept no debt reduction to keep the buffer intact and the next window open.

Once you've stopped buying, the job changes. Rents have usually risen, and reducing debt becomes the priority, because the end goal for most investors is income from property with little or no debt.

For athletes and contract earners, the question is what you can hold on your reliable income, not your best contract year (++buying on contract income++ goes further). A repayment that works on peak income can be too tight after the next contract.

The order in which debt gets repaid across a portfolio is a structure question for your broker and accountant. A buyers agent can show the cash flow either way; they shouldn't choose the loan.

Test both before you choose

When we model a purchase, we use your full pre-approval, count no tax benefits and test the property at a 7% planning rate, so a rate rise or a reset is already in the numbers. You can do the same in the free ++Holding Power Check++, which shows interest only and principal and interest side by side, year by year.

The rule I follow myself: only choose interest only if you could also afford the principal and interest repayment from day one, and you have a reason for the cash it frees up. If you couldn't afford the reset, the lower repayment isn't flexibility; it is a deferred problem.

Take both sets of numbers to your mortgage broker before you decide. If you'd like the purchase modelled as part of a plan, see how we work on our ++buyers agent for property investors++ page. Could you hold your current loans if every interest only period ended tomorrow?

Frequently asked questions

Is interest only better for investment property?

It depends on your position, and it's a question for a licensed mortgage broker. Interest only frees cash for a buffer or the next deposit, but doesn't reduce debt, often costs a higher rate and resets to a larger repayment.

What happens when an interest only period ends?

The loan switches to principal and interest over the remaining term. On my $687,750 of borrowing, a five-year interest only period ending would lift the repayment from about $4,450 to about $5,200 a month.

How much more is principal and interest than interest only?

On my own $655,000 purchase, principal and interest over 30 years would be about $4,930 a month against about $4,450 interest only, about $490 a month more. Your broker can run your own numbers.

Disclaimer: The information in this article is general in nature and does not take into account your personal objectives, financial situation, or needs. It is not financial, legal, or tax advice. The Nelis Group accepts no liability for actions taken based on this content. You should seek independent advice from a relevant licensed professional before making any decisions and always confirm the latest rules and thresholds with your state revenue office or relevant authority.