The short answer: It can be, but only if you can hold the property afterwards. I watched a forced sale go for about $145,000 below what comparable local sales supported. That discount only becomes a gain if you keep the property through the next bad year, and building that holding power usually costs some purchase power.
Why a forced sale looks like a bargain
I’m a buyers agent, and I inspect properties for clients across several markets. Forced sales get more attention when values soften. I read each one I come across as a warning about holding power, and it’s the test I’d want any buyer to run on their own position before making an offer.
Lower prices and thinner competition make it look like the buyer holds every card. It’s the case I hear most often from buyers when values soften, usually followed by one question: how much can I get off? That question skips a step.
What one forced sale showed me
I inspected a property for a client it suited at the time. I knew the selling agent well, and the early feedback was clear: an offer around the top of what comparable sales supported would get it done. The seller’s expectation sat higher, which is common early in a campaign, and the property stayed on the market.
My client changed direction before auction, so we never made an offer. I kept watching anyway. By auction day the sale was forced, and it went for about $145,000 below the low end of what comparable local sales supported, based on the sale price in Cotality’s records. Those comparables still hold. That gap is at the extreme end of what I see.
The property was the same house on auction day as it was when that early feedback came through. The seller’s ability to wait was gone, and once that happens the market sets the price on a single day, with whoever turns up.
What forced that sale stays private. Some forced sales come from life events no plan can prevent. Many of the others come from something more predictable.
How buyers lose their holding power
The predictable ones usually trace back to the approval. A buyer gets approved for the most a lender will offer and borrows close to it, without testing what happens if rates rise or their income drops at the wrong time. With no buffer, one bad year is enough to end the plan.
Buying from that seller gets you their price. Whether you avoid their outcome depends on how your own purchase is set up.
Test whether you can hold before you negotiate
Before you negotiate, ask whether you could carry the property through a year with a rate rise and a vacancy at the same time, without dipping into the money you live on. A mortgage broker can model the repayment side for your loan. The part only you can answer is whether your buffer sits separately from your deposit, or whether it’s the same money counted twice.
Keeping a buffer usually means buying at a lower price point, or buying later. You give up some purchase power. In return, you can stay put when the next shock arrives.
Who this suits and who it doesn’t
This suits buyers looking ten years ahead who can set money aside after the deposit. It doesn’t suit a plan that needs every dollar to go into the purchase. In that case, waiting until the buffer exists is usually the better call.
The rule I use: if you couldn’t hold it through a bad year, don’t negotiate the price yet.
If your income took a hit next year, would you still own the property you’re looking at now?
Frequently asked questions
Are forced sales a good opportunity for property buyers?
They can offer a lower price, but the discount only becomes a gain if you can hold the property through a bad year. Buying from a forced seller doesn’t protect you from the same outcome.
Why do property owners end up in a forced sale?
Some forced sales come from life events no plan can prevent. Many others trace back to borrowing close to the maximum approval without a buffer for higher rates or lower income.
How can I tell if I can hold an investment property through a bad year?
Ask whether you could carry it through a rate rise and a vacancy at the same time without touching the money you live on. A mortgage broker can model the repayments for your loan.
If you want a structured framework for making your next property decision, the free 10-day email series covers each decision in order. www.thenelisgroup.com.au/insights
Disclaimer: The information in this article is general in nature and does not take into account your personal objectives, financial situation, or needs. It is not financial, legal, or tax advice. The Nelis Group accepts no liability for actions taken based on this content. You should seek independent advice from a relevant licensed professional before making any decisions and always confirm the latest rules and thresholds with your state revenue office or relevant authority.
