The short answer: Rentvesting suits people who want to live somewhere they can't or shouldn't buy, and can carry rent and an investment at once. In our worked example, both sides together cost $6,310 a month before any tax benefit. It doesn't suit anyone who needs a settled home soon, or whose budget only works if rent never rises.
Rentvesting is two decisions, not one
I'm a buyers agent, and I've rentvested since 2018, when my first property, bought in 2014, became an investment and I started renting. I grew up hearing that rent money is dead money. I still rent where my family wants to live, and own property where the long-term numbers make sense.
Rentvesting separates two decisions that usually fight each other: where you want to live, and where your money should be working. Your home is chosen on lifestyle. Your investment is chosen on fundamentals: location, price pressure and rental demand, often in a different city.
That separation is the strength. It is also where it goes wrong, when lifestyle preferences creep into the investment choice, or when people model the investment and forget the rent.
Who rentvesting suits
- You love where you rent, but buying there would stretch you or wouldn't make a good investment.
- You'd rather start building than wait to afford the "right" home in the right suburb.
- Your income can carry both sides, with room left for a rent rise.
- You'll want a home one day, and you want the first purchase to support it, not block it.
Many of the rentvestors we work with are young professionals and athletes in their twenties and early thirties, renting near work or training and buying in markets they may never live in.
Who it doesn't suit
- You need a settled home soon, such as a growing family that wants to stop moving.
- Your budget only works if rent never rises. It will, and you'll move sometimes.
- You'd buy in your own suburb anyway because you know it. That's a lifestyle choice dressed up as an investment one.
- You'd lose a first home concession you're relying on. Owning an investment first can affect some first home buyer concessions. Check with your broker and accountant before the first purchase, not after.
The full cost: both sides of the ledger
Most rentvestors model one side. Here is an illustration with both:
Each month
Amount: Your rent, after a renewal increase $2,730
Other fixed living costs $2,000
Investment holding cost, at full pre-approval
$3,750 Less the investment's rent, after two weeks' vacancy−$2,170
Both sides together $6,310
Room left from a $9,500 take-home income $3,190
Illustrative only: a $540,000 loan at a 7% planning rate, interest only, rent $520 a week, no tax benefits counted.
Then the buffer: 6, 9 or 12 months of holding costs across everything you own plus the next purchase, with no rent counted. On this example, six months is 6 × $3,750 = $22,500, held before you offer. The free ++Buffer Calculator++ works out yours.
The trade-off is plain in those figures. You're carrying rent you'll never own and an investment that costs you each month, and the buffer is cash not working toward the next deposit. In return, you get to live where you want while you build.
The figures don't show what you give up by not owning the home you live in:
- The main residence exemption. A home you live in is usually exempt from capital gains tax when you sell. An investment isn't, so part of any gain goes to tax. I'm not an accountant; ask yours how it applies to you.
- First home concessions. Duty concessions and grants are usually for owner-occupiers.
- Investor loan rates, which can be slightly higher than owner-occupier rates. Your broker can compare them.
- Being close to the property. You won't drive past it. I treat each property like a small business: a property manager I trust, regular reports and maintenance kept up, so it doesn't need me nearby.
The costs on the renting side people forget
Rent rises at renewal, and leases end. A move has its own cost.
When my landlord asked for $30 a week more, a bigger house across the road came up at our current rent, so we moved. On price alone it didn't stack up: $1,560 a year saved against more than $2,000 upfront in a bond clean and overlapping rent. We moved for timing, space and being a strong tenant, not to save money. I wrote up the numbers in ++is moving to save $30 a week on rent worth it?++.
Keep room on your own side for that. A rent rise or a forced move shouldn't come out of the investment's buffer.
The Rentvest Test before you buy
Four checks, and all four should clear:
- Strategy. Can you say the job of this purchase in one sentence?
- Cash flow. Does your buffer cover at least six months across everything you own plus this purchase?
- Capital. Is your deposit or usable equity available today?
- Both sides. Is there comfortable room between your take-home income and your rent plus the investment's net cost?
Any check open means pause and set a date to close it. If the both-sides check is tight, look at a lower price point, a higher yielding market, or wait until your income or rent changes.
The free ++Holding Power Check++ works out the investment's net monthly cost, so you can add it to your rent and see the total.
Plan the home you'll buy later, and review as you go
Most rentvestors want a home of their own one day. Three questions shape the first purchase:
- Will you keep the investment when you buy a home? Then it needs to be a property you'd hold while also carrying a home loan.
- Where will the home deposit come from? ++Equity++ in the investment, savings or both. Your broker can show how lenders would treat the investment loan when you apply.
- When will you make the move? When the numbers support it: equity or savings for the deposit, a buffer still in place, and borrowing capacity checked with your broker. Not just when the pressure to "just buy something" builds.
Selling the investment to fund a home may trigger capital gains tax, and tax treatment changes when a property moves between investment and home. Both are questions for your accountant before you buy, not when you sell.
Between now and then, review the plan when the renting side changes: a renewal, a rent rise or a move. Those are the moments that test a rentvestor's plan, more often than the market. Check the buffer is back at target each time, and keep a record of what the investment actually costs in the free ++Property Ledger++.
The rule: rentvest only if both sides together leave comfortable room in your take-home income, and the buffer is in place before you offer. Our ++rentvesting buyers agent++ page shows how we plan both sides with you. What would both sides cost you each month at today's rent?
Frequently asked questions
Who is rentvesting good for?
People who want to live somewhere they can't or shouldn't buy, can carry rent and an investment at the same time, and would rather start building now than wait to afford a home in their preferred suburb.
What does rentvesting really cost?
Your rent and living costs plus the investment's net holding cost. In our worked example, both sides came to $6,310 a month before tax benefits, with a $22,500 buffer held before buying.
Does rentvesting affect first home buyer concessions?
It can. Owning an investment first may affect some first home buyer concessions. Check with your mortgage broker and accountant before the first purchase.
Disclaimer: The information in this article is general in nature and does not take into account your personal objectives, financial situation, or needs. It is not financial, legal, or tax advice. The Nelis Group accepts no liability for actions taken based on this content. You should seek independent advice from a relevant licensed professional before making any decisions and always confirm the latest rules and thresholds with your state revenue office or relevant authority.
