Skip to content
Buyersagents.com.au
Should I buy property in a falling market?

Should I buy property in a falling market?

11 Nov 2026
4 min read
37 views

The short answer: It can make sense if you plan to hold for 10 years or more and can absorb further falls. National values fell 6.7% from their March 2026 peak, but what you pay and where you buy matter more than the headline. The trade-off: values may keep falling after you buy.

The national figure hides very different markets

I’m a buyers agent, and in October 2026 I ran fresh Cotality estimates on every property my clients settled on that year.

Cotality’s national index had fallen 6.7% from its March peak after seven straight monthly falls. Across my clients’ 2026 purchases, the combined estimated value sat about 2.5% above what they paid, and nearly nine in ten were valued at or above purchase price.

The national figure is an average of very different markets. Capital city values fell 8.1% from their peak, while regional values fell 3.1%. By September 2026, upper quartile houses in Sydney and Melbourne were down more than 10%.

Price paid matters more than timing

Automated valuations on recent purchases lean heavily on the price paid, so those estimates are not growth. What they do show is that buying at the right price gives you room when the wider market turns.

Most of those purchases were off-market, so buyers weren’t competing in bidding wars or under auction-day pressure. When a client reaches the 12 or 24 month mark, their broker orders three bank valuations to check where the property really sits, rather than relying on online estimates alone.

Buying in a falling market has a real cost

A falling market gives buyers more room to negotiate and more stock to choose from. It doesn’t make the bottom easy to call, and I don’t try to.

The cost is that values may fall further after you buy. Regional markets fell too, just more slowly. If a further drop or another rate rise would force you to sell, the negotiating room isn’t worth taking.

Who a falling market suits

A falling market can suit you if:

  • you have solid equity or savings for a deposit, plus a buffer set aside
  • you’re in a buying phase of your portfolio and holding for 10 years or more
  • you’d rather negotiate on price than compete for it

It suits people looking 10 years ahead, not six or twelve months.

The decision rule

If you’d judge a purchase by where it’s valued next year, waiting is the better call. If you’re holding for a decade and could ride out another fall without selling, use the market’s negotiating room on price, not to stretch your budget.

Before you look at property, check your borrowing capacity with a licensed mortgage broker. Then ask yourself: would you still be comfortable with this purchase if values were lower in 12 months?

Client figures are based on purchases settled in 2026, including those valued below purchase price, using Cotality automated valuation estimates as at October 2026. These are estimates, not formal valuations. Market data from the Cotality Home Value Index to 31 October 2026 and the Cotality Monthly Housing Chart Pack, September 2026. Past performance is not a reliable indicator of future results.

Frequently asked questions

Is it a good idea to buy property when prices are falling?

It can be if you plan to hold for 10 years or more and can absorb further falls without selling. If you’d judge the purchase by its value next year, waiting is the better call.

Are property prices falling everywhere in Australia?

No. To October 2026, capital city values fell 8.1% from their peak while regional values fell 3.1%, and upper quartile houses in Sydney and Melbourne fell hardest.

Can I trust online property valuations after I buy?

Treat them as a first read. Automated estimates on recent purchases lean heavily on the price paid, so bank valuations at the 12 or 24 month mark give a clearer picture.

If you want a structured framework for making your next property decision, the free 10-day email series covers each decision in order. www.thenelisgroup.com.au/insights

Disclaimer: The information in this article is general in nature and does not take into account your personal objectives, financial situation, or needs. It is not financial, legal, or tax advice. The Nelis Group accepts no liability for actions taken based on this content. You should seek independent advice from a relevant licensed professional before making any decisions and always confirm the latest rules and thresholds with your state revenue office or relevant authority.